Get A FREE Home Valuation!   LET'S DO IT!

23565 Willow Island Trail, Oak Creek, CO 80467

Enjoy lake view living in this beautiful home in the desirable Meadowgreen Subdivision in Stagecoach. This recently constructed three bedroom, two and half bath home features terrific views from every window including Stagecoach Lake, Young's Peak and the old Stagecoach Ski Area. The main level open and sunny floor plan is accented with vaulted beetle kill pine tongue and groove ceilings. A wood burning fireplace takes center stage in the living room, and can be converted to gas if desired. The spacious kitchen has a full suite of Samsung appliances with black stainless finish. Textured black granite countertops complement the custom knotty alder cabinetry with soft close drawers. Quality floor coverings are found throughout the home including distressed wood look tile, hickory wood laminate, custom tile and carpet. You'll find recessed LED lighting throughout the home and Euro Style Buderus hot water radiators provide energy efficient heating for the home. The master suite has a view of the lake and features a walk-in closet and en-suite bath with tiled shower, heated towel rack, and custom concrete topped vanity with embedded Lapis, Turquoise and Agate. In addition to the master, the lower level has two additional spacious bedrooms, a full bath and large laundry room. There is a heated two car garage as well as an additional shed roof covered parking area. There is a large deck that enjoys beautiful views of the surrounding mountains and Stagecoach Lake and is wired for a hot tub. Stagecoach offers amazing recreational opportunities including world class fishing, boating, biking, and cross country skiing. The Steamboat Ski Area is less than a half hour away and is accessible via paved roads all the way from the house. This unique and charming home is a must see. Note: the taxes for 2020 include $2,777.71 for the Local Improvement District payoff. These additional payments run through the 2023 taxes, then the L.I.D will be fully paid.

General Features

Prop TypeSingle Family
Total Beds3
Total Baths3
TypeSingle Family Residence
ArchitectureMountain Contemporary
Parking3 Space(s)
Garage TypeDriveway-Gravel,Heated Garage
Year Built2018
HeatingHot Water, Propane
SewerPublic Sewer


Above Grade2,400 SqFt
Finished2,400 SqFt
Total2,400 SqFt
Land Size0.57 Acres (24,829 SqFt)
Note: All dimensions, including square footage are estimates and must be verified by the buyer.

Level Information

Taxes & Fees

HOA Fee$125
HOA FreqAnnually


School DistrictSouth Routt RE-3
ElementarySouth Routt
Middle/Jr HighSoroco
Senior HighSoroco




Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Electric Water Heater, Microwave, Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Washer

Driving Directions

Cross the bridge at the mouth of the reservoir. Up the hill and Willow Island Trail will be the third road on the left. The home is on the left.


StatusUnder Contract 2021-04-25
Loan TypeCash, Conventional
ConditionsNone Known
Seller TypeIndividual
Days on COListings59

Listing Office


Additional Details

Trail(s), Breakfast Nook, Ceiling Fan(s), Concrete Counters, Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Granite Counters, High Ceilings, Open Floorplan, T&G Ceilings, Vaulted Ceiling(s), Walk-In Closet(s), Meadow, Sloped, Deck, Lake, Mountain(s), Ski Area, Valley, Water


All information on this property was provided by the listing agent. Please contact us and we will happily research any missing information for you.